Spring 2027 Global Affairs & Public Policy IA4952 section 001

Bad Science, Bad Policy - Improving Glob

Bad Science, Bad Policy

Call Number 16441
Day, Time & Location View Class Schedule & Location in Vergil
Points 3
Grading Mode Standard
Approvals Required None
Instructor Natalia Pasternak Taschner
Type SEMINAR
Method of Instruction In-Person
Course Description

Science advice is in high demand. However, it is also under constant scrutiny and scientific evidence itself has been often contested.  What happens when science is ignored in this process? This course will examine case studies of failure and success where scientific evidence was needed to inform policy in different scenarios, countries, political and historical contexts. What happened in situations where science was ignored, distorted or misused in public policies? What was the political context? What could have been done differently? And in the successful cases, how was the evidence used to inform policy? What can we learn from these models?


To cite a few examples, one of the case studies covered in the course is the history of HIV denialism in South Africa and its consequences. To explore the consequences of not heeding medical advice in public policy students we will examine the case of how the South African government handled the HIV/AIDS crisis in the 1990s-2000s. South Africa was so severely affected by the AIDS pandemic that more than a decade later the country still has one of the largest HIV positive populations in the world. Positive examples are also used in the course. Students will learn about cases of success, such as the HIV/AIDS health policies in Brazil, where major prevention campaigns were organized and treatment was included in the public healthcare system and available for all. This comparison will provide students with one positive and one negative example of how science or ideology can influence decision making and policy.


Students will explore policy documents, media coverage, as well as government regulations and campaigns, to draw a landscape of the decision-making processes that led to different results.

Department Global Affairs and Public Policy
Enrollment 0 students (9 max) as of 6:06PM Thursday, November 19, 2026
Subject Global Affairs & Public Policy
Number IA4952
Section 001
Division School of International and Public Affairs
Open To Columbia College, General Studies
Section key 20271GAPP4952U001